Opinions have little value

Last year I read an interview with Feri Pal, an extraordinary clergyman, who is also a mental health specialist and a former athlete. A couple of his thoughts grabbed my attention. He came up with the following answer for one of the questions:

“A few years ago I put it like this for myself – it will probably sound harsh – the opinion of people does not raise my interest. The reason is that the meaning of the word ‘opinion’ is not very rich. Maybe there is no knowledge, depth or truth in it. (…) nowadays everyone has an opinion. Lots of people want to express or share there opinion in one form or another. To my experience, it only adds to the cacophony and shallowness in the world. I don’t feel that these opinions would be of too much value. If someone tells me their opinion about say, happiness, I don’t get excited. However, I would be interested to hear when and what made her happy. I am also intrigued to learn what she is doing to become happy, and how she can get through the failures while seeking happiness. All of these I’m interested in. The world of opinions is too shallow for me, and shallow things I find boring.”

Building on these thoughts I have collected what seems a lot more useful to share with others or listen to, especially in work context:

  • observations
  • specific experiences
  • personal reflections on experience
  • data
  • description of a situation/problem
  • analysis
  • deliberations
  • feelings
  • possible scenarios/options
  • solutions proposed
  • ideas
  • questions
  • requests
  • summarising what was understood
  • highlighting key points, etc.
I have felt several times in my life that I am just not interested in certain opinions that I hear but I would never have been able to word it so bluntly. Perhaps you need a good deal of self confidence to admit. No matter, what the opinion of other people will be.

More blog posts:

What’s wrong with a “bring the solution, not the problem” attitude?

It is quite understandable that we don’t want our colleagues to keep complaining to us about problems and not take responsibility for the solution. But if we expect them to come to us only when they have the solution as well, they may be afraid to tell us and withhold problems that we should be aware of. Fortunately, it’s not that difficult to avoid the constant whining by creating a safe environment for colleagues to feel free to tell us their problems and bad news:

Read more »

Minden nagyszerű dolog tákolással indul, csak nem ott fejeződik be

Megfigyelésem szerint van néhány igen elterjedt gyakorlat és tévhit, ami megakadályozza az embereket abban, hogy nagyszerű dolgokat hozzanak létre. Az egyik ilyen az igénytelenség, melynek megnyilvánulásaként még azokat az egyszerű feladatokat is szarul végzik el, amit nem sokkal több erőfeszítéssel vagy gondolkodással egészen jól meg lehetne csinálni. Mindenki találkozott már a “jóvanazúgy” jelenség tipikus megnyilvánulásaival. Ennek a skálának a másik pólusán helyezkedik el az az attitűd, hogy rögtön világszínvonalút szeretnénk létrehozni, az viszont sajnos nemigen reális. Azok, akik erre képessé váltak, legyen szó technológiáról, üzletről, sportról vagy művészetekről, évtized(ek)ben mérhető gyakorlással, kísérletezéssel, közbülső mérföldkövekkel, irányváltásokkal, újbóli nekifutásokkal, kapcsolatok építésével, szerencsés eseményekkel (amiket persze részben maguk tettek lehetővé) és kitartó munkálkodással jutottak el odáig. Csak erről nem mindig szól a fáma, illetve nem látszik, mi van a jéghegy csúcsa alatt.

Read more »

Why is there little learning when coaching others?

Listening is a very powerful tool for a good manager. A good coach does not give advice, only asks questions. Coaching mindset, operating with questions, is essential to be a successful manager. All sound pretty good, in theory, but I don’t share that view honestly. I do agree that it is very annoying to be an asshole who has answers for all the questions, even to those ones that have not been raised. On the other hand, going by questions alone leaves little room to develop others. Let’s think about it…

Read more »